u could use mac eyeliner..and it cost $14...but what i use the most..and it does not smudge..is a mac eyeshadow...pick a dark color ( the color that u would want ur eyeliner)...which is $15...and buy a thin angles brush..i recomed u to but it from a drug store cause brushes are mostly the same..and macs is expensive..but draw the eyeliner that u want with the eye shadow and use the angled brush to draw it...it shouldnt smear becuase its eyeshadow..and alot of people/celebraties do this too..i use eyeshadow with a angled brush more than my eyeliner

put a lid primer or concealer under your eyes, use a gel liner with a brush to apply the eye liner, and then set it with a matte black eyeshadow. boom.