Also depends on where your needs are. Let's suppose westbrook and fitz about equal each other in fantasy points (which granted is a stretch). That leaves mcfadden and edwards vs wayne and mccoy. We have no way of knowing how much time mccoy will get; he's certainly not a 3rd down/goal line guy. Edwards reported late to camp and then got suspended as I recall, so more of the same from him, plus he has to play the world's greatest football team twice, the poor sot. Call them roughly even, with the edge to edwards just because winslow is gone. wayne vs mcfadden? mcfadden is listed behind fargas on the depth chart, and wayne will surely have a decent year. so that's the only place you've got the edge to that side. I'd say overall, fitz/mcfadden/edwards is the better trio
Edwards is junk, trust me on that (living in northeast Ohio), and McFadden has question marks, but Fitzgerald will churn out remarkable Fantasy numbers. I don't believe Wayne will be in the same area code as Fitz when it comes to stats and you are getting two Eagles RB, one being a rookie. I say hold onto what you have and then do your homework & try to deal Edwards (and McFadden) for a "sleeper"...there will be owners banking on names and that's where you can solidify your club.
It depends on how your fantasy pool is set up as far as a points system goes; generally, RBs score the highest, so I'd pick Brian Westbrook first of those players. That said, Larry Fitzgerald is a fantasy beast as well!
Answers & Comments
Verified answer
I think the person getting larry fitzgerald would benefit more because essentially you are only getting one player between westbrook and mccoy.
Also depends on where your needs are. Let's suppose westbrook and fitz about equal each other in fantasy points (which granted is a stretch). That leaves mcfadden and edwards vs wayne and mccoy. We have no way of knowing how much time mccoy will get; he's certainly not a 3rd down/goal line guy. Edwards reported late to camp and then got suspended as I recall, so more of the same from him, plus he has to play the world's greatest football team twice, the poor sot. Call them roughly even, with the edge to edwards just because winslow is gone. wayne vs mcfadden? mcfadden is listed behind fargas on the depth chart, and wayne will surely have a decent year. so that's the only place you've got the edge to that side. I'd say overall, fitz/mcfadden/edwards is the better trio
Edwards is junk, trust me on that (living in northeast Ohio), and McFadden has question marks, but Fitzgerald will churn out remarkable Fantasy numbers. I don't believe Wayne will be in the same area code as Fitz when it comes to stats and you are getting two Eagles RB, one being a rookie. I say hold onto what you have and then do your homework & try to deal Edwards (and McFadden) for a "sleeper"...there will be owners banking on names and that's where you can solidify your club.
It depends on how your fantasy pool is set up as far as a points system goes; generally, RBs score the highest, so I'd pick Brian Westbrook first of those players. That said, Larry Fitzgerald is a fantasy beast as well!
Westbrook.
larry fitzgerald is a defenite. mcfadden, not worth it. the rest are pretty good values
braylon edwards and darren mcfadden arnt to good.