I realize that Psych is a comedy and Dexter is serious, and they both have very different plots.

But they are also both crime-solving, law-enforcement type shows. Also, both Dexter and Shawn have annoying ex-police dads who give them terrible advice. Also, they both live in sunny states.

I realize my similarities are pretty lame, but still: If you had to pick ONE of those shows to watch, which would you and WHY? Explain, please!

Thanks!