Verified answer

Don't be too hasty to jump into something that has a lot of spin. You can get the Vokeys without the spinmill feature. From what I can tell by your question, that may be the better option for you. I myself am a +2 handicap, so I know that the more spin you have, the less control you have over the shot. I play the Vokey SMs myself, but I wouldn't suggest it to almost anyone I know because of how difficult they are to handle. If you want a wedge that has the most consistent quality in the areas of performance, feel, and control, you should look into the Clevelands or the regular Vokeys. As for the lofts, you may not want to rush into a 60 degree. Many people I know are now using a 54 and a 58, so they can have that added height without losing all playability of the short shots. I could try and tell you more, but to make the actual decision, you would have to go to a retailer and try the wedges out yourself. What it comes down to is which one feels the best to you.

No one can give you a good answer to that question. They are both excellent wedges. I think the more important question is how much bounce should they have. Where do you play? Conditions? What's your handicap? I don't want to sound like a jerk, but if you're asking cleveland vs. titleist, you probably should not be carrying a lob wedge. Go PW, Gap, SW.

Titleist Spin Milled

Test out both before buying - I am a Titleist man - but the Clevelands may suit your swing better.

Vokey oil can wedge. Soft feel, good spin, can get rusty and looks great.

The obvious answer is: the one that works best for you.

Go to a store that has a facility that allows you to hit a few irons and you decide. No one else can do that for you.

I would say the Titelist wedges....

because they are spin milled and you can get more spin with it... but the cleveland wedges are lighter in feel....